Today is November 8, 2026 / /

The Torah Learning Library of Yeshivat Chovevei Torah

Beginning Again: The Torah We Have Yet to Hear

by Rabbi Ysoscher Katz (Posted on October 8, 2026)
Topics: Bereishit, Sefer Bereishit, Torah

Download printable pdf here >

For many years, my wife and I spent summers in Israel with our two boys. On the way, we would stop in a different European country for a short family vacation.

One year we chose Berlin. Our boys were four and six at the time. While the younger one could not yet appreciate the historical weight of the visit, his older brother was beginning to grasp its significance.

Of all the sites we visited, the remnants of the Berlin Wall made the greatest impression on him. He was intensely curious about its history and eventual demolition, and we shared an age-appropriate account.

Soon it became clear how deeply the story had affected him: he kept asking us to tell it again. We obliged, preserving the basics but adding something each time: a new detail, a different angle, perhaps a bit more color. By the time we left Berlin, we must have told him the story thirty times.

Around this time of year, I am always reminded of that experience.

As we embark on another cycle of Torah reading, it is hard to avoid a sense of déjà vu. Again we are going to read about creation, the flood, and the lives of our patriarchs and matriarchs? Don’t we know these stories already? Did we not hear them last year, the year before that, and the year before that?

Well, that is not what our son taught us. He understood that one can hear the same story many times and still find each telling illuminating and enlivening.

If that is true of stories in general, how much more so of the Torah, whose words we return to every year.

As I have mentioned before, the students of the Ba’al Shem Tov teach that Mattan Torah was not a one-time occurrence. It happens anew whenever we read from the Torah. Kri’at HaTorah carries within it something of the encounter at Sinai. Consequently, we encounter a “new” Torah every year, week after week.

The words given at Har Sinai are eternal; our encounter with them is renewed. Certain narratives and mitzvot spoke deeply to us last year, while others remained distant. This year, those same passages may speak differently. A story that once seemed remote may suddenly address the very questions with which we are struggling.

The Rambam, commenting on the final Mishnah in Makkot, explains that the abundance of mitzvot gives each person an opportunity to fulfill at least one wholly lishmah, without an ulterior motive. That abundance also invites us to consider the different ways we find our place within Torah.

We will not experience every mitzvah with equal intensity at every moment. We remain bound by them all, but some become particularly sustaining expressions of our avodat Hashem, deepening our closeness to God.

The Torah’s narratives offer a parallel abundance. Their richness allows us to discover, at different moments in our lives, dimensions of God’s words the meaning of which we could not previously apprehend. Sometimes it is precisely our longstanding intimacy with a text that allows us to hear what we could not hear before.

This Shabbat, therefore, when the ba’al kri’ah chants the opening verses of Parshat Bereishit, allow yourself to encounter the Torah anew, to experience a personal Mattan Torah. Perhaps you will discover something that was not there, for you, last year.

Even if it eluded you in years past, even if these passages did not seem to speak directly to you, listen again. Perhaps this year a familiar word will disclose an unfamiliar depth, or a note in the biblical symphony will suddenly resonate, entering your soul and awakening something within it.

Allowing yourself to hear these stories anew may reveal חלקך בתורה, the portion of Torah uniquely entrusted to you. This is more than finding a passage that speaks to your circumstances. It is also discovering what your encounter with Torah can bring into the world: an understanding that emerges through your particular life and the spiritual work it asks of you.

If you do not open yourself to discovering that portion, it may never come to light, leaving all of us deprived of something only you can disclose. A Sefer Torah is invalid if even a single letter is missing. Metaphorically, you may be entrusted with a letter whose place in our shared Torah has yet to be revealed. Discovering it is therefore both a personal spiritual task and a responsibility to Klal Yisrael, whose shared portion in Torah is enriched by what each of us brings to light.

There is good reason to expect that we will notice something new. Since we last heard these stories, we have grown, but we have also borne another year of life’s sorrows and wrestled with questions that do not yield easy answers. Our relationship with God has acquired another year of history as well. God does not change, but His relationship with us continues to unfold within our lives. We return to the same words carrying more of life’s weight, and a deeper longing to hear what God asks of us and offers us within it.

For myself, I look forward to discovering what these familiar stories and mitzvot will disclose this year, and what I will hear that I could not hear before.

I am curious. You should be curious too.